Who can resist the classic, tangy, and savory flavors of a Reuben sandwich? It’s a beloved deli staple, but for those of us on a health journey, especially with programs like Weight Watchers, a traditional Reuben often comes with a hefty point count that can quickly derail our goals. The good news? You don’t have to miss out on this incredible flavor! Our Turkey Reuben Panini Sandwich offers all the satisfaction without the guilt, clocking in at just 6 WW points. Opt for a lighter bread, and you can even bring it down to a mere 3 WW points!

This recipe is not only delicious but also incredibly versatile, allowing you to use thin slices of quality deli turkey breast or even repurpose leftover turkey from holiday meals. It’s an excellent way to get back on track after indulging during festive occasions like Thanksgiving or to enjoy a themed meal for St. Patrick’s Day. If you’re constantly on the lookout for exciting Weight Watchers sandwich ideas or inspiring Weight Watchers lunch recipes, this lighter Turkey Reuben is about to become your new favorite!

🥘 Essential Ingredients for Your Turkey Reuben Panini

Crafting the perfect Turkey Reuben Panini requires a few key ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need, along with some helpful tips for each:

• Oven-Roasted Turkey Breast: The star of our sandwich! For convenience, thinly sliced cold cuts or deli turkey work perfectly. If you have leftover roasted turkey breast from a holiday meal, it’s an excellent way to utilize it. Ensure your turkey is lean to keep the sandwich Weight Watchers friendly.
• Low-Fat Swiss Cheese: A traditional Reuben relies on Swiss cheese, and for our lighter version, low-fat Swiss slices are ideal. Many grocery stores offer excellent low-fat options that melt beautifully. Avoid processed Swiss cheese slices, as they often have a different texture and less authentic flavor. The mild, nutty flavor of Swiss cheese pairs wonderfully with the other ingredients.
• Sauerkraut: This fermented cabbage is crucial for the Reuben’s distinctive tang. You can find canned or jarred sauerkraut near other canned vegetables and pickled items. Some stores also carry fresh or refrigerated versions, often located near the deli or produce section. If plain sauerkraut isn’t available, wine sauerkraut is a suitable alternative, though it tends to be slightly sweeter. The most important step here is to drain it extremely well and squeeze out as much liquid as possible *before* measuring and adding it to your sandwich. This prevents your panini from becoming soggy.
• Rye Bread: The quintessential bread for a Reuben. Any type of rye bread will work, from light rye to marbled or dark rye. Choose a sturdy bread that can hold up to the fillings and the pressing of a panini maker without falling apart. For those closely tracking Weight Watchers points, consider a lighter, lower-calorie rye bread to further reduce the point value without sacrificing that signature rye flavor.

*See the comprehensive recipe card below for exact quantities and a full list of ingredients.

📖 Creative Variations & Easy Substitutions

One of the beauties of this Turkey Reuben Panini recipe is its flexibility. Feel free to customize it to your taste or what you have on hand:

• Bread Choices: While rye is classic, don’t hesitate to experiment with other types of bread. Whole wheat bread or a multi-grain option can add nutritional benefits. For an even lower Weight Watchers point count, explore very light or reduced-calorie breads specifically designed to be WW-friendly. Just ensure your chosen bread is robust enough to handle the panini press.
• Mustard Magic: Yellow mustard provides a classic tang, but switching to Dijon mustard can introduce a more sophisticated, slightly spicier kick. For an authentic Reuben feel, consider a homemade light Russian dressing or Thousand Island dressing, prepared with light mayonnaise or Greek yogurt, to keep it healthy and flavorful.
• Protein Alternatives: If turkey isn’t available, or you’re simply craving something different, this panini works wonderfully with other lean proteins. Leftover cooked chicken breast, either shredded or thinly sliced, makes an excellent substitution. Deli chicken breast is another quick and easy option.
• Cheese Options: If low-fat Swiss cheese isn’t your preference or is hard to find, other low-fat cheeses like provolone or mozzarella can also be used. They’ll melt beautifully and offer a slightly different flavor profile while keeping the points low.
• Add Veggies for Crunch: To boost the nutritional content and add extra crunch, consider adding a few thin slices of red onion or a layer of fresh spinach before pressing.

7. Step 7: Cook in Batches. For best results and even cooking, avoid overcrowding the panini grill. I recommend cooking no more than two sandwiches at a time. This ensures consistent pressure and heat distribution.

8. Step 8: Grill Until Golden. Cook the paninis for approximately 5 minutes. The exact time may vary slightly depending on your panini press and desired crispness. You’re looking for beautifully grilled, golden-brown ridges on the bread and thoroughly warmed fillings.

9. Step 9: Ensure Melted Cheese and Serve. The panini is ready when the cheese inside is fully melted, and the bread boasts those appealing golden-brown grill marks. If your cheese hasn’t completely melted but the bread is crisp, some panini presses have a “melt” setting or you can simply let it sit closed for an extra minute or two. Repeat the grilling process with any remaining sandwiches. Serve immediately, perhaps with a side of dill pickles, for the best experience!

Top Tips for the Perfect Turkey Reuben Panini

Achieving panini perfection is easy with these helpful tips:

• Prevent a Soggy Sandwich: This is arguably the most important tip! Sauerkraut contains a lot of moisture. To avoid a soggy panini, drain and vigorously squeeze out excess liquid from the sauerkraut before you add it to your sandwich. You can use a fine-mesh sieve or even a clean kitchen towel for this.
• Choose the Right Bread: Rye bread is traditional and offers fantastic flavor. When selecting your bread, look for a sturdy variety that can withstand the pressing without becoming too compressed or mushy. If you’re using a lighter, lower-calorie bread for Weight Watchers points, consider lightly toasting it in a regular toaster before assembling. This pre-toasting step will give it extra structure and prevent it from becoming overly soft during the panini press.
• Strategic Layering for Even Melting: For optimal flavor distribution and melting, place your cheese slices directly against the bread. This creates a protective barrier, preventing the bread from absorbing too much moisture from the other fillings and ensuring the cheese gets wonderfully gooey.
• Mastering the Panini Press: Always preheat your panini press fully before placing the sandwiches inside. This ensures immediate searing and those coveted crisp grill marks. Avoid the temptation to overcrowd the press; cook in batches if necessary to ensure each sandwich receives even pressure and heat. No panini press? No problem! You can achieve a similar effect using a large cast-iron skillet. Place the assembled sandwich in the skillet over medium heat, then press it down with another heavy pan (like another cast iron skillet or a pot) placed on top. Flip and cook until both sides are golden and the cheese is melted.
• Skip the Butter, Embrace the Mustard: Traditional Reubens often call for buttering the outside of the bread. To keep this recipe lighter and Weight Watchers friendly, skip the butter entirely. Instead, spread a thin layer of mustard directly on the inside of the bread. Mustard not only adds a delicious tang but also helps to prevent the bread from drying out during grilling without adding unnecessary fat or points.
• Serve Immediately for Best Texture: Paninis are at their absolute best when enjoyed fresh off the press, while the bread is crisp and the fillings are warm and gooey. If you’re preparing them for a crowd or meal prep, it’s best to store the individual ingredients separately in airtight containers in the refrigerator and assemble and grill them just before serving.

🔢 Understanding the WW Points for This Delicious Panini

Eating healthily on Weight Watchers doesn’t mean your meals have to be bland or boring. This grilled Turkey Reuben Panini is a testament to that! With its rich flavors and satisfying crunch, each sandwich is only 6 WW points. For those aiming to further reduce their points, simply opting for a lighter rye bread or another low-calorie, Weight Watchers-friendly bread can bring the point value down to an impressive 3 points per sandwich. When you consider that a traditional Reuben sandwich typically racks up a whopping 24 points according to the WW app, our turkey version is an incredible, guilt-free alternative!

👪 Serving Size & Adjustments

This Turkey Reuben Panini recipe is designed to yield 4 delicious sandwiches, making it perfect for a family meal or for prepping a couple of lunches. If you need to adjust the quantity, it’s incredibly easy! Simply click on the blue serving number within the recipe card below and select your desired number of servings. The ingredient quantities will automatically adjust, saving you time and effort in scaling the recipe up or down.

🌡️ Storage Guidelines

For the best flavor and texture, paninis are always best enjoyed fresh. However, if you plan to make components ahead or have leftovers, proper storage is key. Store the ingredients for this hearty sandwich—the cooked turkey, drained sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese slices—separately in individual airtight containers in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. The rye bread can be stored at room temperature in its original packaging. When you’re ready to enjoy, simply assemble and grill a fresh panini!

As I mentioned, one of my favorite Weight Watchers sayings is: “It’s not what you eat between Christmas and New Year’s, but what you eat between New Year’s and Christmas that really matters.” We often get so focused on overdoing it during the holidays and then feel guilty. It’s truly okay to indulge a little, but the most important thing is to consistently get back on track with your healthy habits. The cumulative effect of your daily choices throughout the year makes the biggest difference. And since it’s always “between New Year’s and Christmas” at some point, this sandwich is a perfect, delicious way to use up that leftover Thanksgiving turkey or simply enjoy a fantastic meal any time of year!

❔ Frequently Asked Questions About This Recipe

Did your family ❤️ this recipe? Did you know that commenting and ⭐ rating recipes is one of the best ways to support your favorite recipe creators? If you LOVED this recipe, please comment and rate it in the recipe card below or share photos on social media using the hashtag #foodmeanderings or tagging @foodmeanderings!